Nationwide Home Insurance Review (2026)
Nationwide earned 4.2 / 5 in our 2026 review. Best for: brand new belongings replacement cost coverage. Here is the full breakdown.
- +Brand New Belongings pays to replace items at today's prices, not depreciated value
- +Better Roof Replacement upgrades your roof materials when you file a claim
- +Vanishing deductible rewards claims-free years
- +Home renovation credit for upgrading plumbing, electrical, or HVAC
- +Multi-policy discount for bundling with auto
- +Identity theft protection available as add-on
- -Not available in Alaska, Hawaii, Louisiana, or some coastal areas
- -Some specialized coverage only available through agents
- -Premiums above average for high-value homes
Coverage available
Nationwide includes the six standard parts of a home policy. Flood and earthquake coverage are excluded by default, which is industry standard. Add them as separate policies if you are in a high-risk zone.
Nationwide is the right pick if you prioritize brand new belongings replacement cost coverage. It earns top marks for claims process. If you do not match this profile, compare against the other top picks on our home insurance hub.
Overview
Nationwide carries an AM Best financial strength rating of A+, which matters more in home insurance than almost any other line. When a hurricane, wildfire, or hail storm hits a region, claims can spike fast. A well-capitalized carrier pays them. A weak one can struggle. The carrier writes policies in All 50 states and is best known for brand new belongings replacement cost coverage.
Premiums for a typical $300K single-family home, $250K dwelling, and a $1,000 deductible run $1,400 to $1,900 per year with Nationwide. That puts the carrier around the middle of the home insurance market. Of course, premium varies sharply by ZIP code, home age, roof condition, claims history, and credit.
On customer satisfaction, Nationwide scored 812 on the latest JD Power US Home Insurance Study. That puts it right around average. The digital experience is rated good.
How to get a Nationwide quote
Getting a quote from Nationwide takes about 10 to 15 minutes online. You will need your home address, year built, square footage, roof type and age, and an estimate of the dwelling replacement cost. Most carriers also ask about prior claims in the last 5 years and your current insurance status.
- Visit the Nationwide home insurance page
- Enter your address, home details, and coverage info
- Pick coverage limits (set dwelling to replacement cost, not market value)
- Review the quote and apply bundling and other discounts
- Bind the policy online or speak to an agent
Frequently asked questions
Ready to get a Nationwide home quote?
Takes about 10 minutes. No commitment to bind.